Monday, November 27, 2023

Can I Replace Just One Tire

Achieving Optimum Car Handling Through Tire Replacement

Subaru Tire Blowout – Replace All 4 Or Just One

Replacing all four tires helps drivers achieve optimum car handling, gaining comfort and road traction on the road. Replacing one tire at a time presents car handling challenges down the road. The new tire will have a different tread depth, altering its accelerating and braking abilities compared to other tires.

According to Firestone Auto Care, replacing one tire results in significant wear imbalances between tires, which can adversely affect your cars general performance and stability. At the same time, your cars electronics and mechanical system may find it hard to explicate information from the tires when one is distinct from the rest.

Some car manufacturers have specific restrictions against replacing fewer than four tires. Therefore, you should check your owners manual before replacing any of your car tires.

Different Tread Depths Lead To Less Stability

Speaking of tread depths, the designs in your tires arent just there to look sick

The tread is what helps your tires, and therefore your car, stick to the road, no matter what the situation. Whether youre taking a sharp turn or driving in inclement weather, like rain or snow, the tread on your tires is critical to keep you and your vehicle safe from skidding out.

When you have a tire with a different tread depth than the others, in this case, one new tire out of four, you significantly reduce the amount of grip you could otherwise expect. Because the balance of the tires is off now, they just wont hold on the way they would if they were all equally worn down.

Can You Replace Just One Tire

Theres nothing worse than realizing youve popped a tire, especially when it happens in the middle of a busy day. When you arrive at the repair shop, the mechanics will likely try to sell you on a full set of tires, but you may be wondering if thats really necessary.

Weve put together this guide to help you weigh the pros and cons of buying a single tire.

You May Like: Best All Season Tires Suv

How Does Tire Damage Occur

There are certainly situations where you may be in a position where only one tire needs to be replaced. Oftentimes this occurs during blowouts, flats, or if you roll over something in the road and it punctures the tire. Tires are pretty resilient, but various factors can cause them to weaken or otherwise get damaged.

You can easily puncture one of your tires by running over broken glass, a nail, or another sharp object that punctures the tire. Likewise, the environment can put a strain on your tires, causing them to weaken and potentially tear or blow out. Not to mention, driving over potholes can put a strain on your tires, and accidents can also damage them.

While tires are built to withstand a lot, there are still plenty of factors that can lead to a rip, tear, hole, or leak, causing you to need to replace one, or several, of your tires. However, most people will tell you that if you need to replace one tire, youre probably going to need to replace them all.

Can I Replace Just One Tire On My Subaru Is It Safe

Can You Replace Just One Tire On A Car

When you get a flat tire on your Subaru, it can be a costly inconvenience that forces many drivers to ask if they can just replace one tire instead. If its just one tire that needs to be replaced, check for tire wear and tread depth on the other tires first. You need to ensure that your tire will maintain proper balance if only one tire is replaced.

Recommended Reading: Bf Goodrich Tires For Sale

Replacing One Tire On Fwd Or Rwd

Replacing only one tire on the front-wheel drive or rear-wheel drive vehicles is less critical than on all-wheel drive vehicles, but still important. If you have the option to replace one or two tires, you should always replace two tires if your budget will allow it.

If you must replace only one tire, match the new tire with the best one of the cars remaining tires and mount them to the rear axle. Try to match the brand and tire model with the current tires as well.

Why Replacing 1 Tire On Awd Vehicles May Not Be Best

Mismatched tires on AWD vehicles are one of the most common reasons for drivetrain damage. Saving money by only replacing 1 tire will cost you more money when the drivetrain needs to be fixed. There should be no tread difference between any of the tires on your vehicle. To ensure there are no variances in tread depth, be sure to replace all four tires at the same time with the same brand, same size, and same type.

Don’t Miss: Black And Decker Tire Inflator

If You Must Replace Only One Or Two Tires

Perhaps you only have the time and money to get one tire replaced. Or, your tire technician has evaluated the existing tread depth on your car’s remaining tires, checked the vehicles owners manual and determined that replacing one tire is okay. Whatever the reason, here’s how a replacement of only one or two tires generally works.

Do I Have To Replace Tires In Pairs

Replacing Just One Tire

When replacing your tires, you will most likely be told you would need to replace tires in pairs, instead of telling you to replace just one tire. You probably wonder why is this so and why is it necessary?

There are a few instances where you can replace just one tire, but in general, this is only when the rest of your tires are fairly new. In most cases, you are required to replace your tires in pairs. On some all-wheel drive vehicles, the manufacturer may even recommend the replacement of all four tires.

Here are reasons why you are required to replace all tires:

  • The variation between the tread can increase wear on the new tire and lead to it wearing out faster than the older tires, making it counter-intuitive.
  • When you replace just one tire, that tire can spin at a slower rate sending false signals to anti-lock braking systems and traction control. This can lead to dangerous errors. On all-wheel drive vehicles, it may l
  • ead to the system engaging unnecessarily, which can at best waste your fuel and damage your system at worst.
  • The new tire will get more or less traction than the old tire, adversely affecting the behavior of your vehicle when accelerating, braking or cornering. More often than not, this will reduce the safety and performance of your vehicle.
  • Uneven tire wear can damage traction control, all-wheel drive systems, and even physical aspects of the vehicle over time. In addition, it can also make the vehicle less efficient which also reduces gas mileage.

Also Check: 275 60 15 Tires For $65 Each

What Sort Of Tire Should I Get For Just One Wheel

This is actually a really important question here because it might seem like a no-brainer to just get another tire thats equivalent to the one that was damaged, or split, or was flat. However, there are some important steps to keep in mind when it comes to replacing a tire. For one, you will want to get a replacement tire thats the same as the other tires on the vehicle.

While you may only consider replacing one tire, its not always a bad idea to consider replacing all four if youre heading into a new season and your vehicle is currently equipped with season-specific tires. For instance, if you have a blowout for just one tire at the end of the summer and your vehicle is fitted with summer tires, and you live in a place where the fall is rainy, then it wouldnt be a bad idea to replace all four tires with all-season tires. Alternatively, if one of the tires is flat or damaged, and it takes place during the winter, and your vehicle is equipped with winter tires, then you will need to get another winter tire to match the other set. Things may get a little tricky if a replacement is required in-between seasons, but again, its best at that point to just replace all the tires if you equip seasonal tires.

Old Tread And The Quarter Test

The key component to look out for is your tread. As weve mentioned, this is what keeps you stuck on the road when youre taking a sharp turn, and uneven treadwear, whether from buying a new tire or another issue with your suspension system, is going to be bad news.

But you dont need to have uneven tread wear to need new tires. Even if theyre all evenly worn down, old tires arent going to do the job.

While the old penny test used to be the tried and true method to determine whether its time to start shopping, we firmly believe in the newer quarter test.

Stick our first President’s head in between your tire treads, dont worry, he wont mind. If you can still see the top of his dome sticking out, then its time to start shopping. The reason behind this is that the space between the edge of the quarter and where Mr. Washington’s head begins is 2/16ths of an inch, which is just above the safe zone when it comes to your tread.

The difference between the penny and the quarter test is that the penny only has 1/16ths of an inch, at which point your tires arent going to be doing much good. Its like waiting to evacuate the building until you can see the fire coming at you–you might want to head out once you hear the alarms.

Buying your tires just before they arent safe anymore gives you more time to shop and find the perfect match, like a set of these Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus for only $36 per month.

You May Like: How Often Should You Change Tires

Should You Replace Tires In Pairs

It isnt required but it is recommended by most tire experts. Electronic stability programs and anti-lock braking systems work best with consistent rolling diameters and levels of grip on the same axle.

The reality is that the differences in tread wear between two tires likely wont pose a big challenge to stability programs or mechanical differentials due to rolling diameter differences. The difference between 10/32 and 4/32 is quite small.

The significantly worn treads will have greatly different performance on wet or slick road surfaces, however, and this can be quite demanding for software and hardware to balance between more than one tire with large differences in tire performance.

If any of your tires are worn to 4/32 of tread depth remaining you should consider replacing them since they are near the end of their usable life and will perform

How Long Does It Take To Change A Tire Yourself


Generally speaking, though, changing a tire is relatively straightforward. If youre a handy person and you can use the most common car repair tools, youll be able to complete the task by yourself. It shouldnt take any longer than 15 to 30 minutes.

How Much Should 4 new tires cost? According to recent reviews, Angies List members report paying an average cost of $637 to replace four tires, with a range of $525 to $725. According to CostHelper, a standard, all-season tire costs between $50 and $200 each with an average price of $80 to $150.

How to Change a Tire: A Step-by-Step Guide

What month is best to buy tires?

And heres the secret: Buy your tires in or April to save the most on your new set of wheels. Tires go on sale in October to encourage consumers to buy before winter and again in April when the weather gets warm enough for people to start thinking about road trips and joy rides.

How long do tires usually last? On average, people drive between 12,000 to 15,000 miles a year, which means the average good quality all-season tire will last somewhere between three and five years, depending on maintenance, driving style and conditions, etc.

Read Also: 5.00-15 Tractor Tire

Visit United Tire & Service For Quality Tires And Auto Repair Near You

AtUnited Tire & Service, our staff is here to serve customers throughout Pennsylvania. We offertop-quality auto repair services done by expert technicians. From an oil change or brake repair to auto air conditioning repair, muffler repair, engine diagnostics, wheel alignment, car batteries, fleet repair, tire repair, suspension repair and Pennsylvania state vehicle inspections, we do it all. We also stock a wide selection oftires from all the top brands in the industry including Goodyear Tires, Dunlop Tires, Kelly Tires, and many more.Schedule an appointmentwith us today at one of our locations inAmbler, Bethlehem, Concordville, Downingtown, Emmaus, Feasterville, Phoenixville, Southampton, Paoli, West Chester or Willow Grove, PA. We are your number one source for top quality, affordable auto repair and tires!

Driving With One Different Size Tire

No matter your situation, you should never mix different size tires. Slightly different tire widths are okay front to rear, but not side to side. This is assuming you have the clearance if they are wider and they will fit the wheels.

Different rolling diameters should be avoided since they would wreak havoc on the stability control systems and possibly the transfer case or differential.

Recommended Reading: 2014 Nissan Altima Tire Size

Why Replacing A Single Tire Is Not A Good Idea

You may have heard from your neighborhood car expert that it is just OK to save cost by replacing tires one-by-one, but, unless you can vividly recall which tires you replaced and when, you should always aim at replacing all four car tires at once.

New, freshly installed tires have superior traction compared to the old ones that have been on your car. Therefore, mixing up both will result in your vehicle lacking uniform grip on all wheels, compromising its stability in substandard road conditions, which in turn increases the risk of accidents. It is also challenging to get a matching tread set when you buy a single tire all the time.

What About Two Tires

Subaru Tire Blow Out Replace All Or One? NA

Alright, so weve covered that buying one tire isnt really a good idea. But what about just buying two tires?

If youre in a situation where time and money are limited, and the idea of four tires seems like a lot, you can probably get away with just picking up two tires. Because the two new tires can fit the same axle, theyll be balanced with each other and not put any strain on your suspension system.

Granted, with our flexible payment plan, we make sure that even the tightest pockets can afford to pick up a set of four all at once without having to drop some serious coin at one time. Not to mention we offer free installation when you swing by one of our Rent A Wheel locations which you wont find at too many other shops.

However, while your axle will be balanced, your tires still wont match up. This is especially frustrating when the time comes to get new tires. You could end up in a difficult place, where you need to replace your front tires but dont want to swap the rears because you already bought new ones, and vice versa when the time comes to replace the rear tires.

Buying two tires might seem like a good idea, but it can throw off the maintenance and scheduling of your vehicle, which are both important to keep track of.

You May Like: 265 70 R17 All Terrain Tires

Is It Ok To Have Mismatched Tires

Essentially, you should not have mismatched tires you should not mix different tire brands and different tread patterns. There are very rare instances for approved mismatched tires, but generally, manufacturers do not recommend tire mixing.

For optimal performance and safety, it is recommended to fit the same tires to every wheel position on your vehicles. Drivers must have the same size, brand, tread pattern, speed rating on the front and rear tires.

As a bare-minimum, tires must meet the recommendations in terms of size, load index and speed rating as indicated by the auto manufacturer. This is a legal requirement in several countries.

If you drive a car with a set of mismatched tire sizes, load indexes, constructions or speed ratings, you are putting yourself and other road users in danger. It is always best to stick with the auto manufacturers specifications or consult a qualified tire specialist.

If mixing becomes an unavoidable option due to budget constraints or lack of availability, it is still possible to mix tire brands and tread patterns as long as you fit a pair of tires with the same brands and tread patterns across the same axle meaning you should install a pair of identical tires on the front axle or a pair of identical ones to the rear.

Is It Possible To Just Replace One Tire On A Vehicle

Tires are one of the most important parts of your vehicle, but they can be one of the most complicated to deal with at times. There are numerous types of tires, sizes, recommended tire care guidelines, and it can be confusing to keep it all straight. Plus, tires are expensive. Cheap tires that are good quality can be hard to come by, so many people may find themselves asking, can I just replace one tire? In short, the answer is yes, but there are only some circumstances where replacing one tire is the best course of action. Most of the time, you are going to want to replace at least two or all of your tires.

Don’t Miss: No Credit Check Tire Financing

Recommendations That Don’t Fall Flat

Replacing a single tire isn’t always a good idea. Thankfully, with Firestone Complete Auto Care’s selection of affordable tires with free installation services, you don’t need to change just one tire! Help maintain solid control of your vehicle and visit your trusted local tire experts for repairs and replacements that are Fixed Right, Priced Right, Right on Time!

Latest news
Related news